Localizing the Planetary Boundaries framework: How to preserve its conceptual coherence while fostering its territorial operationalization?

français

Speciality : Mathématiques Appliquées en Sciences Sociales

14/12/2026 - 14:00 Damien Rieutor (UGA) amphi de la MACI

Keywords :
  • Analyse systèmique
  • Gouvernance locale
  • Aide à la décision
  • Alternatives sociotechniques
  • Contextualisation
The Planetary Boundaries framework sets boundaries for habitability at the global scale, yet has little influence on the local decisions that nevertheless contribute to their transgression. Hence the research problem: How can this framework’s effective capacity to guide action at the subregional scale, its territorial operationalization, be improved? The first finding, drawn from thirty-four literature reviews, is the operational paradox of the dominant approach to localizing this framework. Intended to drive the framework’s territorial operationalization, the top-down quantification of its numerical components tends to create, or does not overcome, the eight challenges that stand in its way. The second finding is drawn from a contrast case following the dominant approach and four cases localizing Doughnut Economics, which couples the same quantification with exogenous social components, juxtaposed with the Planetary Boundaries framework. Their analysis reveals the operative dilemma of the additive socio-biophysical architecture. The contrast case is weakly operationalized but limits the dilution of the framework’s systemic nature, taken as a criterion of conceptual coherence. The Doughnut cases show the opposite. These findings impose a dual necessity on the research question: Is it possible to develop an approach to localizing the Planetary Boundaries framework that maintains its conceptual coherence while improving its operationalization at a French subregional scale? My full answer, the downscaling of the Planetary Boundaries canvas (PB.canvas), combines four original conceptual and methodological contributions. The PB.canvas, a biophysical, ethical, and socio-anthropological interpretation of the Planetary Boundaries concept, defines each component by conceptual invariants. Contextualization, a new participatory localization approach, has local actors redefine the biophysical components of the PB.canvas under the constraint of their invariants. Decomposing biophysical processes into spheres and flows supports the cross-scale systemic continuity of the Planetary Boundaries framework. A causal framework, DAPSSIRC, organizes this downscaling, and a manual supports it. For lack of a field site for the downscaling, the test is restricted to contextualization without co-construction, limited to the nitrogen and water cycles. I submitted a contextualization report on the selected site to a local stakeholder and five scientists. The results amount to a dissociated corroboration of the hypothesis. The maintenance of conceptual coherence is corroborated: The dilution of the framework’s systemic nature is similar to that of the contrast case, and the invariant preservation rate is high. However, the potential for operationalization is only partially corroborated: The results suggest better handling of feasibility and perceived legitimacy, but only relative to the contrast case. Thus, contextualization neither dissolves the operative dilemma nor reproduces it unchanged: It shifts the trade-off to the choice of the normative boundary, where the dilemma recurs only if the chosen boundary is less restrictive than the threshold. Only one shortcoming is clearly attributable to the method: Without an identified threshold, the continuity of the Planetary Boundaries framework is not ensured at the step where the boundary is set. The answer to the research question is affirmative but bounded: undemanding non-corroboration conditions, an experiment with six participants, and my dual position as designer and evaluator, hence a proof of concept with user feedback. The research problem receives a conditional answer, shared between the method and the territory: Improving territorial operationalization first means changing what travels from one scale to another, then traceably grounding what does not travel, the boundary itself.

Directors:

  • Guillaume Mandil
  • Gwendoline De Oliveira Neves